The Question I Would Have Asked

You’ll probably be disappointed. The meeting was mainly for Pelosi to campaign for two local Pennsylvania women running. They never discussed opposition or even the existence of opposition. The message, over and over, was “We’re gonna win and take back Congress.” Interesting, seeing as Republicans are focusing on terrorism (Don’t lose everything, including close family members) and it’s working. I had a high school teacher talk about the difference in rhetoric between Democrats and Republicans. Democrats give out messages like “We’ll do this together;” “We need your help to take back Congress;” and “We’re gonna make a stronger America;” where Republicans are much more likely to say, “We’ll take care of you;” “Leave politics to us, just vote for us;” and focus on trust and values issues.

Pelosi managed to contradict herself by talking about how Democrats have a united front, but also that the party has diverse opinions. It was frustrating to listen to her and the other people speak. I don’t like politics, Republican or Democrat. Unfortunately, because of the two-party system, these are your choices, at least if you want your vote to mean something. I think the time is ripe for a third party, a moderate progressive party. It’ll only work if it can steal votes from both sides but the time’s ripe. No one likes Congress right now.

So this is the question I would have asked. Remind me, if I’m ever meeting with college students, to just sit and let them talk, rather than spoonfeed them and ask for clarification later.

Mrs. Speaker:
I spent a lot of my week leading up to this meeting trying to convince people of all political stripes, not just Democrats, to come and see you speak. I wasn’t trying to get them out here because I think they need to agree with you, but to strengthen their own views through discourse and debate, like the Greeks did in their great democracy two thousand years ago. But I get the feeling that many young people, in fact so many Americans today, are scared of listening to anyone that disagrees with them. I can’t talk about politics at the dinner table. Liberals are stuck in a feedback loop, reading the New York Times and watching CNN, and Republicans hear what they want, reading the Wall Street Journal and watching Fox News. Meanwhile, each side is playing to their base, strengthening it and drawing a line in the sand. As you said a few minutes ago, “You have a choice between fear-mongerers and hope.” President Bush earlier this week said “177 of the opposition party said ‘You know, we don’t think we ought to be listening to the conversations of terrorists.” The only thing everyone can agree on, the bipartisanship you were talking about, is railroading a ban on online gambling through Congress, and only because everyone’s scared of looking soft on terrorism. There’s no chance of a middle ground when you have that rhetoric. My question to you is, what happened to the middle ground, and when are Congressmen of all stripes going to start working for the good of America and not their own partisan agendas?

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s